Yay, I got some scanning done! I've been trying to do a more realistic style with most of these.
I did [link] 's meme:

1. Scarecrow
2. Ragdoll (3)
3. Junior
4. Joker
5. Rorschach
6. V
7. Easter ([link] 's OC)
8. Dara (my OC)
9. Sibh (my OC)
10. Stark
11. Scorpius
12. Sephiroth

Let's get this disaster started.

1- 2 and 11 decide to audition for a play together. 9 is the director. What play do 2 and 11 audition for, and what does 9 think about this?
Macbeth.
Sibh thinks Ragdoll is insane and irritating and that Scorpius is pretty good. She also wonders how she got talked into directing a play

2- 3 wants a pet. 8 agrees to take 3 to the pet store to pick one out. What pet does 3 pick, and what does 8 have to say about this?
Junior picks a cute puppy, then kills it. Dara runs away.

3- A burglar breaks into 7's house in the middle of the night. How does 7 react to this?
Probably frightens them off, maybe kills them.

4- If 1 and 5 had their own T.V. show, what would it be called, what would it be about, and who would play them?
Masked information.
It would be about science (from the scarecrow) interspersed with random rants about imorality (from Rorschach).
They would play themselves. It wouldn't last long!

5- What is 4's theme song?
People Hate Me - By the Murderdolls

6- 12 gets bored and decides to seduce 6. What does 12 say, and how does 6 react?
"Your fighting prowess is quite extraordinary."
V invites Sephiroth to a fencing match.

7- 10 got fired from their job and now must find a new one. What did they do before, and what do they do now?
He was a slave. How can you get fired from that? Well he became a fugative.

8- 8 decides to serenade 11, and proceeds to do so under 11's balcony. What song does 8 use qo serenade 11, and what is 11's reaction?
Dara can barely talk. He plays Move Along by the All American Rejects on his guitar.
Scorpius brings him inside and tries to figure out what's wrong with him.

9- 8's plan is going great until 4 becomes annoyed and marches out, demanding that 8 shuts up, then begins throwing things at 8. 11 tries to get 4 to stop, inadvertantly kills 4. 8 and 11 panic, then decide to bury the body and not tell anyone. How did 11 kill 4, and what happens next?
He throws him against a wall.
It turns out he's not dead and gives them both a fright. (You can't kill the Joker!)

10- 2 and 10 get the opportunity to take 6 shopping. They decide to change 6's look completely. What did they change it to, and what does 6 think?
They dress him in a technicolour suit with one side of his mask cut off.
V hates it.

11- What is the most unlikely pairing of characters in this meme?
Junior and Dara

12- 5 agrees to rough it in the wilderness for three weeks. They have the option of taking one other person with them and a survival kit. Who do they take with them, and what is in their survival kit?
He takes Dara and brings a pocket full of sugar cubes, his diary and his grapling gun.

13- 1 and 7 get Lost. (Ben sucked em through the TV or something.) How do they react to the Losties? To the Others? (If you don't watch Lost, have 1 and 7 play CSI or Law and Order)
I don't understand this question.

14- what would happen if 12 and 3 decided to play doctor?
Junior ties up Sephiroth and tries to cut him open with her scissors and tortures him for a while before he escapes.

15- 9 and 5 think there's a map on the back of the Declaration of Independance. 5 decides to steal it. What does 9 do? (this really works if the character you picked for slot 5 was played by Sean Bean :3)
Asks what it's a map to.

15- The Repo Man is after 10. Why? (Again, if you haven't seen Repo, then a serial killer is after 10)
He has lots of people in his head so it'll be like killing thousands (millions?) of people at once.

16- Who would you trust with sharp things, 1 or 4?
Neither but deffinately not the Joker.

17- 6 swears they saw someone lurking outside the window. 2 decides to investigate. What happens?
There is someone. Ragdoll waves and introduces himself in an excited manner. The potential burgular is frightened away.

18- 3,8, and 11 all walk into a bar...
Everyone else leaves.

19-What is 7 afraid of?
His cousin.

20- 9 and 12 are stuck spending the day together. What do they do for fun? Do they get along?
They practice fighting. They get on well.

21- 5,3, and 1 have been assigned a top secret mission to go undercover in a sting operation. What are their disguises?
Rorschach: A very battered looking suit, his hat and scarf hiding most of his face.
Junior: A potatoe sack (read The Secret Six!)
Scarecrow: An old coat (to hide the Arkham jumpsuit)

22- 1-12 are all contestants on America's Next Top Model. Who wins, and why?
Easter.
The Scarecrow thinks the whole thing is ridiculous. Ragdoll loves it but is horribly scarred and too creepy. Junior refuses to show even a milimeter of skin and kills anyone who suggests it. The Joker enjoys it but terrifies everyone (and again scarred). Rorschach calls everyone prostitutes and walks out. V is (again) very scarred and also won't take off his mask. Easter might be a transvestite but he is pretty and somewhat willing to dress up. Dara is too shy. Sibh is too muscular and short. Stark is missing half his face and unable to sit still. Scorpius can't take off his thermal regulator suit. Sephiroth finds the whole thing boring. (He comes second)

23- 7 has just died. The rest are depressed, and it is up to 2 to make them feel better. What does 2 do?
A strange dance.

24- 4 wants to seduce 12. How does 4 do so?
Tries to drive him (more) insane.

25- 6 is trapped in a closet with 11 and no one is there to open the locked door.
They have a long phisisophical discussion

26- 8,10,11,and 5 play Truth or Dare. 8 dares 5 to kiss 11. What is 10's reaction?
giggles

27- 1 has to tell 6 something important, and doesn't want anyone else to overhear. What is it?
"I'm going to spray everyone with fear gas. Would you like to help?"

28- What does 2 want to be for Halloween?
Wonder Woman

29- 9 and 12 are running from the cops. Why are they running?
They killed lots of people (who somewhat deserved it)

30- 9 and 12 need someplace to hide from the cops. Who hides them?
Scorpius

31- 10 and 11 are plotting to kill 4. Why are they plotting to kill 4, and how are they going to pull it off?
They want to stop him killing everyone.
They never get far into the planning. Stark starts screaming at Scorpius for torturing him for two years.

32- 3 has ordered a mob hit on 7. What did 7 do to deserve it?
Being friends with her brother.

33- Something is haunting 8's house, and 11 offers to help Exorcise the house.
ok

34- Who would 12 rather date, 7 or 1? How would 12 ask them out, and what would they say?
Easter I think.
He would attempt to be really confident but fail. Easter would tease him but agree.

35- 10 is having 2's child. What does 2 have to say about it?
"Can we dress it as a monkey?"

36- 5 finds out that 10 is having 2's child. 5's reaction?
Tries to rescue child.

37- 3 and 9 spend the night together. Tell us about that.
They both survive. Just.

38- 4 and 6 decide they both like 8 and start fighting over 8. Who wins, and what is 8's reaction?
V wins.
Dara is terrified.

39- 3 and 10 decide this meme is too long, and rather boring, and decide to leave. Where do they go, and what do they do?
Junior goes back to her crate. Stark goes to look for Zhann (his dead lover).

40- 11 has been wanting to confess their undying love for 5 for a long time, and RIGHT NOW is their chance. How do they go about doing it?
Eloquently but rater insecurely.

41- 1 gets into an epic, bloody fight and gets mortally wounded protecting their true love, 9. 9 has to hold 1 in their arms whilst 1 dies. Describe their tragic last moments.
"You were trying to protect me? Why??"
"I think perhaps (cough) the Hatter has (cough) slipped me a mind control card."

42- write a love scene between 7 and 12.
He ran a hand down the boy's skinny hip. So delicate...

43- 2 and 4 want to get away from this meme, so they decide to go on vacation. Where do they go?
California.

44- 6 and 8 are surrounded by zombies. Only one can survive.
Well V unless he sacrifices himself or something.

45- 10 decides to study magic and casts a spell on 12, accidentally turning 12 into a platypus. How does 10 go about fixing this?
He panics and starts smashing stuff.

46- What would happen if 1,4, and 8 went fishing?
The Joker would push the other two out of the boat.

47- 9,5, and 11 went for a road trip and got lost. 5 wants to stop for directions, 9 is being stubborn and refuses, and 11 really has to pee.
sounds amusing

48- 2 and 6 stay in to watch horror movies. They get drunk. What happens?
Dancing!

49- Do 3 and 7 get along?
No

50- So, the meme is over, and as a parting gift from DeviantScar, 1-12 all get one wish. What is it?
Scarecrow: become the god of fear
Ragdoll: a swimming pool full of jello
Junior: make everyone suffer
Joker: be killed by Batman
Rorschach: Blaire Roche not to have died
V: Anarchy
Easter: to kill his cousin
Dara: for horrible things to stop happening
Sibh: for Dara to be happy
Stark: to be with Zahnn
Scorpius: the Scarrans not to be a treath to the Sebaceans
Sephiroth: to know who his parents are.

51- Okay, so it's not quite over. 1, 5, 9, 4, and 11 each get to choose a Deviant for you to tag. Who tags whom?
don't know